نوع مقاله : پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
The transition from physical environments to digital spaces has fundamentally transformed the concepts of privacy and evidentiary searches. This study aims to delineate the boundaries of lawful access to personal data and messaging applications through a comparative analysis of Imami jurisprudence, Iranian criminal law, and international human rights standards governing fair trial. Employing a descriptive-analytical methodology based on documentary research, the study examines the legal and jurisprudential foundations of digital searches. The findings indicate that, while Imami jurisprudence upholds the general prohibition of tajassus (intrusive investigation and surveillance), it recognizes limited exceptions grounded in jurisprudential principles such as the preservation of public order and necessity. These exceptions demonstrate a degree of convergence with the principles of necessity and proportionality recognized under international human rights standards. Nevertheless, Iran's legal framework faces significant challenges, including ambiguity in distinguishing searches of physical devices from access to digital accounts and the absence of effective mechanisms for deleting irrelevant data. These shortcomings may facilitate indiscriminate searches and violations of the right to privacy. The study concludes that reforms to Iran's Criminal Procedure Code and cybercrime legislation are necessary to ensure that access to messaging applications is subject to specific, narrowly tailored judicial warrants and that binding protocols are established for the deletion of irrelevant or excessive data. Such a balanced regulatory framework could enhance the effectiveness of criminal investigations while preventing the dominance of an absolute security-oriented approach over digital privacy, thereby safeguarding individual liberties and maintaining an appropriate balance between security and freedom within the criminal justice system.
کلیدواژهها English